Gas Heater vs. Electric Heater Pros & Cons

If you are considering installing a new heating system and are trying to answer questions like, which is more energy efficient, electric or gas? Or, which costs less? You’ve come to the right place. Whether you’re building a home or replacing your existing heating equipment, learning more about your options will help you make the right decision for your needs. The following article will explore the pros and cons of gas vs. electric heating systems to help you decide on the best choice for your home.

How Does a Gas Heater Work?

When comparing gas vs. electric heating, it helps to understand how each system functions. A gas heater operates by burning natural gas to create heat. Inside the heater, burners ignite the gas, producing a controlled flame that generates warmth, which is then distributed throughout your home.

This heat transfers to a metal component called a heat exchanger. A fan then draws in cool room air, which passes over the hot heat exchanger, becoming warm. This warmed air is blown back into the room through your vents, raising the room to the desired temperature.

Gas Heater Pros

Using a gas heater system comes with several advantages. Gas heaters tend to warm spaces quickly and effectively. They offer consistent heat output, ensuring comfort during cold weather. Depending on where you live, gas may be cheaper than electricity, which will increase the cost savings on your heating bill.

If you live in an area that receives a lot of winter storms, you’ll take comfort in knowing your gas heater will continue working even during power outages, making them very reliable during severe weather. They are also more environmentally friendly when compared to some other heating methods.

Additionally, modern gas heaters have safety features that make them a very low-risk heating option. Installation is usually straightforward when performed by a professional, and while gas heating systems do require furnace maintenance, it’s minimal. Overall, a gas system provides efficient, fast, and cost-effective heating, making it a popular choice for many households. Keep these benefits in mind as you weigh the decision between an electric and gas furnace.

Gas Heater Cons

While using a gas heater for a home certainly offers several benefits, there are some drawbacks to consider. First, a gas heater requires a connection to a nearby gas supply, which may limit placement options within your home. Also, the process of combustion involved in gas heating can release certain pollutants, which can compromise your indoor air quality. Additionally, initial installation costs for a new gas heating system can be higher compared to other heating methods. And the price of gas can fluctuate over time, impacting your heating costs. Regular maintenance is necessary to ensure both the safety and efficiency of gas heaters.

How Does an Electric Heater Work?

An electric heater for a house operates by using electricity to generate heat. Inside the heater, there are coils made of a special metal that heats up when electricity flows through them. As the coils heat up, they transfer warmth to the air around them. A fan or blower then circulates this warm air into the room, raising the temperature. Electric heaters come with a thermostat that lets you set the preferred temperature. Once the room reaches that point, the heater turns off, and when it gets cooler again, the heater switches back on to maintain the comfort level.

Electric Heater Pros

Electric heaters offer several advantages. Firstly, they're easy to install. You just plug them in! They're also quite safe, as they don't involve burning fuel or producing harmful fumes.

Electric heaters are energy-efficient, converting most of the electricity into heat, and they provide quick warmth since they don't need time to warm up. They’re compact and portable, suitable for various spaces. With no need for a fuel source, they're convenient and can be used anywhere with an electrical outlet.

Electric heaters are a simple, reliable way to keep warm. In the gas vs. electric heating debate, there’s no denying the advantages that come with electricity.

Electric Heater Cons

Electric heaters have some downsides to consider. They can lead to higher energy bills if used extensively. While they're efficient at converting electricity to heat, depending on where you live, electricity to operate your heater can be more costly. Also, electric heaters are not great for warming larger spaces as effectively as other heating methods. They also take time to heat up and cool down, so immediate temperature changes can be slower.

Unlike gas heaters, electric heaters won’t work during a power outage. Some models can dry out the air, causing discomfort. Overall, while electric heaters are convenient, their energy costs and limitations in larger spaces are important factors to weigh.

Which Heater Is Right for You?

Deciding between electric vs. gas furnaces depends on your preferences and needs. If you value quick, powerful heat and have access to a gas supply, a gas heater is a good choice. It's effective in larger spaces and works even during power outages. However, if simplicity and portability are priorities, electric heaters might suit your needs. They're easy to set up and don't need a fuel supply.

Keep in mind that gas heaters might have higher installation costs and potential air quality concerns if not properly maintained. Electric heaters might lead to higher energy bills. Choose based on your space, budget, and heating priorities. And when your HVAC system needs service, our team of experienced pros is ready to help.

Get Help Choosing the Right Heater for Your Home

If you're still unsure about which type of heating system is best for your home, we can help. Your local Aire Serv® professional will be happy to discuss your needs, review your options, and help you make the right choice for your home.

We offer top-notch heater installation and maintenance services that will make the entire process easy and hassle-free. To get started, request an appointment online today! Your comfort and satisfaction are our priorities, and we're ready to assist you every step of the way. All our work is backed by the Neighborly Done Right Promise^™, so you can rest easy knowing the job will be done right the first time.